Thank God I finally figured out a combo that he adores and gobbles all up each time. He was off his food quite a bit in the last 3 weeks. So I changed flavour and added a few things.

If he could put on 1lb I would be happier.

He sits at 13lbs right now but his big bones.

Hardy is close to 20 lbs and must be watched so he does not ever eat Laurel's food.

These cats are so groovy and we love them both tremendously. I have finally convinced hubby of the very real wild dangers for cats if they start spending more than 3 hours a day  outside. They often become less affectionate too the more outdoor they are I have noticed (Laurel is no longer a lap cat with either of us- last time was in early march when he stayed on my lap for 10 minutes).

UPDATE

Laurel just had about two thirds of a cup of dry food, plus wet food plus a catto. I will get him to fatten up now! Yay!